Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin has recently presented a comprehensive analysis of the challenges posed by Ethereum’s proof-of-stake (PoS) consensus mechanism. In a detailed post on the Ethereum Research forum, Buterin delved into the systemic complexity emerging from the increasing number of signatures required for validators to sustain the network.
The central issue revolves around the escalating workload burdening validators, pivotal to the network’s functionality. In addition, as the number of validators grows, the demand for generating signatures essential for proper network operation intensifies, straining the system. The situation worsens as significant upgrades are ready to increase signature requirements substantially.
Buterin’s Proposed Solutions: Simplifying Ethereum’s PoS
Buterin’s proposed solutions share a common objective of reducing the required signatures to 8,192 per slot in the Ethereum blockchain. Each solution introduces a distinct approach to address the complexity inherent in the current PoS design.
Therefore, this approach will involve the creation of decentralized staking pools. Increasing the minimum ether required to operate a validator node would increase the pooling and sharing of resources at the level of individual validators. This will help in load sharing and reduction of system burden.
Moreover, a second proposal assumes implementing two layers of stakers with variant requirements. Upon initiating the finalization of the initial ‘heavy’ layer, the system will incorporate heightened requirements into this layer. Simultaneously, another “light” layer includes lighter requirements and adds an additional security layer to the process of block finalization.
The third solution is built on a rotating set of participants – a random choice of validators for every single slot. Even though it would provide efficiency of participation and a decrease in the number of signatures, the complication that would arise from its use at the same time was outlined by Buterin.
Addressing Challenges & Embracing Change
According to the blog post, Buterin emphasized the challenges posed by Ethereum’s commitment to supporting a high number of validators for decentralization. The vast number of required signatures per slot introduces technical challenges, including intricate attestation propagation mechanisms and potential quantum resistance issues.
However, to address these challenges, Buterin proposes moving away from the expectation of an ever-increasing number of signatures per slot. He advocates a philosophical shift to expand the PoS design space, simplify technical implementations, enhance security, and effectively tackle quantum resistance issues.
Moreover, the Ethereum co-founder also explored the drawbacks of a committee-based approach used by some blockchains, emphasizing the importance of accountability in Ethereum’s current system.
Buterin’s proposal aims to establish a clear expectation of 8,192 signatures per slot, providing technical implementers and the Ethereum community with a more predictable future. The decision on which solution to adopt will involve careful consideration of trade-offs, particularly regarding liquid staking and other related issues.
Related Reading | MicroStrategy’s Bitcoin Boost: Stacks More BTC as ETF Speculation Peaks